Most Liked Positive Review

Very Warm, Best Value, Bit Loose

I bought this from TNF Renewed. Had been looking for a deal but with what a great value they are, that never happens. I found the McMurdo by googling for "warmest jacket for sitting still." This and the one named after the northern birds that bring down planes were the highest recommended. However t...hose are over $1,000 and aren't nearly as durable as TNF. The MSRP on this McMurdo is the highest of all my non-merino clothing. I'm glad I bit the bullet, because I'm cold-natured and had been suffering, particularly the last 2 winters after losing 100 lbs. Loves: 1. Warmth. I've only tested this down to upper 30s, but was able to sit outside and not move with only a t-shirt underneath. It'll be in the 20s next week so I'll update (if possible) if that changes. 2. Breathable. Despite being very warm when it's cold, I wore it inside at 68 and was comfortable with just the zip open. That said, I am very cold-natured and have my heat set to 74 in winter. 3. Detachable hood fur. Could see it being useful when I'm visiting Canada, but in NC it just gets in my eyes. 4. Large lined chest pockets for wet gloves. 5. Value. As said above, MSRP is less than 1/3 of what I would've paid for the competitor. Dislikes: 1. Exterior pockets (besides the chest ones) aren't lined with soft material, so when I'm not wearing gloves they aren't comfortable. However, none of the pockets are in a good position to rest your hands anyway (none are angled upwards or at the right position/level to rest your hands with your arms at a right angle) so I don't do this much. 2. Fit isn't my favorite. It looks a little frumpy, but that is somewhat to be expected given the amount of insulation and at this price point. To be lighter, they'd probably need to use less higher-fill-power down, which would be more expensive. I'm usually a S or XS in most things (I have a runner's physique: 37" chest, 30" waist, 36" hips) and prefer a tight fit. I got a S and have a ton of space under if I'd want to layer. I'd prefer to have an option for an XS. 3. Wish the Velcro sleeves were buttons. Dog hair attaches to the Velcro. Honestly apart from fit I'm really nit-picking. I'd definitely buy this again and have already recommended it to a friend who has a similar physique and cold nature.